Where does your money go?

Where does your money go?

To become financially independent, saving a significant portion of your income is at least as important as getting a good return on your assets. This is especially true for those who do not have a 40-year investment horizon, i.e. anyone who does not want to wait until the normal retirement age. In this case, you should focus on the biggest expense items such as taxes and social security, housing, transportation and food. Once you have these points under control, you have done the main thing.

Compulsory expenses (taxes and social security), housing (with charges), transport (private and public) and food (outside and at home) represent in total and on average 2/3 of the gross household income, or nearly CHF 6,300 per month. It should be noted that a household is a group of people sharing the same home and who can have several incomes and expense items. Savings is also an important point in the composition of the household budget, which we will discuss later.

Household spending

Mandatory expenses

Mandatory expenses include taxes, social security contributions (AVS/AI/AC and LPP) and compulsory health insurance (LAMal). These expenses alone represent 27.5% of gross household income, or a whopping CHF 2,650 per month or CHF 31,800 per year!

It is difficult to influence social security contributions if you have a salaried job, unless you lower your income (which is not as stupid an idea as it seems...). So let's focus on other mandatory expenses. Taxes and health insurance represent CHF 1,700 per month and per household, or 17.7% of gross income. That's CHF 20,400 per year. To cover this type of expense for the rest of your life, a portfolio of more than CHF 580,000 would be necessary using a tax rate of 3.5%. According to the study Trinity, this withdrawal rate ensures, with any style of balanced portfolio and in any market conditions, the survival of the capital over a period of forty years. This should be enough, unless you retire very early!

Where does your money go?

Regarding taxes, you can lower them by setting up a 3rd pillar pension account, by buying real estate in order to deduct debt interest and maintenance costs, by deducting training costs, income acquisition costs such as transport and ... by having children! But since many tax deductions are based on other expenses, we often see a transfer of costs from one item to another. Note that there is also the possibility, with a significant impact, of moving to a canton and/or municipality with a more accommodating tax policy.

For health insurance, it's a little easier. You can make the competition work and opt for the highest possible deductible. This has the advantage of taking responsibility for your health, of not going to the doctor for everything and for nothing, and above all of making substantial savings. On the other hand, you have to keep a little cash aside to prevent a big problem. As with taxes, you can try to live in a less expensive place from the point of view of health costs.

READ  NO to the 13th annuity

In my household, I managed to reduce the expenses for taxes and health insurance to CHF 12,000 per year. I would need a portfolio of CHF 340,000 to cover these expenses for my entire life, with a deduction rate of 3.5%. This is still significant, but already more accessible than the figures given above.

 The accommodation

Housing represents the largest financial outlay for households after compulsory expenses. Annual housing costs amount to an average of CHF 18,000 per household per year (CHF 1,500 per month). This still represents 15.6% of their gross income. Using the same withdrawal rate, a portfolio of CHF 515,000 would be necessary to cover these expenses for 40 years. All that, just to put a roof over your head... it's crazy! And with that, you're not even a homeowner and you don't leave anything as an inheritance for your descendants. As long as you buy at a good price, and you can afford it, acquiring real estate is therefore preferable to renting in the long term.

Whether you opt for one or the other solution, the choice of property must in any case correspond to each person's lifestyle. It must not be unnecessarily too big or too far from the workplace. I live with my family in a spacious but not excessive apartment that costs me CHF 13,000 per year in interest and charges. In theory, I would need a portfolio of CHF 370,000 to cover this expense for the rest of my life. But since I plan to amortize this property over a period of about twenty years, my household ultimately only needs a portfolio of CHF 260,000 to cover all the interest during this period. The amortisation is considered as savings, which we will see below.

Reducing your housing costs is a key step in becoming more frugal and making serious progress towards financial independence. Is every room, bedroom, bathroom, toilet, kitchen, laundry room, dressing room... really necessary? Do you need a garage to store a bunch of stuff you never use? Or do you need more time to live your life, spend more time with family and friends? While you think you own your home, it may actually own you...

Food

Eating well, there is nothing like it. However, as with everything in life, moderation is essential. Food represents the third largest expense for a Swiss household, with an average annual cost of CHF 14,400, or 12.6% of their gross income. This amount includes food and beverage products, i.e. goods purchased in stores and consumed at home, but also the entire part relating to catering and hotels. This amount would require a portfolio of CHF 412,000 with a withdrawal rate of 3.5%. To reduce this bill, it is not just a question of limiting restaurant outings. It is also a question of reducing the commission ticket, by frequenting hard discounters for example.

READ  Action Rubis (RUI:PAR) : valeur française & rendement

Food is a very individualistic and relative thing. Buying chicken breasts in bulk and making a small dish with some rice for dinner is cheap and very healthy. Maybe you prefer pasta. Making spaghetti with sauce takes little time and money. Add some meat and you have a hearty meal. cheap. You can prepare large quantities for the entire week. Again, you don't need to be extreme here, but taking your budget seriously will make your ability to achieve financial independence at a young age that much greater. You don't need to eat rice and beans for the rest of your life, just set priorities.

My household is in line with the Swiss average, i.e. CHF 14,400 spent per year on food, both outside and at home. So there is clear potential for improvement from this point of view, but we must still have a few vices!

Transport

Transport is also a major expense for most of us. Private and public transport costs, at CHF 11,000 per year, represent 10% of the gross income of Swiss households. A wallet of CHF 315,000 would be needed to cover these costs. Is it really worth it?

Do you drive a nice, luxurious car to work? Then you probably have a household budget close to the average Swiss household. If what really matters to you is to live more independently by working less, you should reduce your transportation costs as much as possible. Try carpooling. If you live close to your job, buy a scooter, a bike or take the opportunity to walk part of the way. If you live too far away, consider moving or changing jobs. Use public transportation and/or opt for a fuel-efficient car model.

Combining several of these criteria, our household is now at CHF 4,500 per year. A portfolio of CHF 128,500 is sufficient to cover these expenses over the next 40 years.

Savings

Savings are obtained indirectly by adding up all the income of a household from which all expenses are subtracted. Deposits in a savings account, payments for the 3rd pillar, purchases of stocks and bonds, investments, depreciation, etc. are not counted in expenses, so these items are part of household savings.

Each Swiss household saves CHF 1,200 per month or CHF 14,400 per year, or 12.2% of their gross income. I have read some comments on websites from readers who were shocked by this amount, which seemed enormous to them. But let's put it into perspective a little. First, let's not forget that this is an average and that this figure is therefore distorted by some very high incomes, who can afford to save a lot. Then, it should be noted that savings also include debt repayments and/or payments into 3rd pillar pension accounts, which can very quickly represent significant amounts. Furthermore, we are talking about savings per household, not that of a single person. Finally, with 12.2%, Swiss households are far behind the savings rate of the French, which amounts to 16.8% and which a priori do not seem to be particularly economical, at least as far as their public finances are concerned.

READ  Journal d’un futur rentier (61)

The lower your expenses, the greater your savings capacity, the more you can put aside for the future, the less your current and future financial needs are, and the faster you can become financially independent. 12.2% of gross income is frankly not huge, I would even say that it is insufficient if you want to claim to become an early rentier. But for that you have to put a little good will into it and stick to your principles. My E-Book will give you more details on the importance of savings capacity on the path to financial independence.

Conclusion

In terms of the expenses of a typical Swiss household, a portfolio of almost CHF 1,800,000 would be necessary to meet all your basic needs for the next 40 years. As for me, I "only" need CHF 1,100,000 to cover these basic expenses during the same period. That's a difference of CHF 700,000! Of course, even reduced, the basic amount required remains significant, but we are talking about forty full years of retirement, or double that of most people... To refine the details, we would of course have to take into account other expenses, but also the social security to which you will be entitled at retirement age and for which you have already contributed. My E-Book and its Excel tool will give you more details on this.

I want to become financially independent so I can live more and work less. I want to have time for myself. I don’t want to live the daily grind of work-home-sleep until I’m 65. I don’t want to be stuck in traffic on Monday mornings when I could be spending my morning at the beach. Without financial freedom, you don’t have that choice. The sooner you realize that your expenses are holding you back, the sooner you’ll want to cut back on those expenses and the sooner you’ll have freedom!

Sources: 
www.dividendmantra.com/2013/02/the-big-three.html
http://www.lematin.ch/suisse/dixieme-budget-consacre-mobilite/story/14812125
http://web.archive.org/web/20131007075753/http://www.nyx.net/~anon8248/ret1.htm
https://www.phn.com/Portals/0/PDFs/Francais/Articles/taux_de_prelevement_a_la_retraite.pdf
http://web.archive.org/web/20131115154442/http://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/portal/fr/index/themen/20/02/blank/key/einkommen0/niveau.html
http://web.archive.org/web/20091023071447/http://www.bfs.admin.ch:80/bfs/portal/fr/index/themen/07/03/blank/ind24.indicator.240105.2401.html
 

Discover more from dividendes

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

16 thoughts on “Où va votre argent ?”

  1. Hello,
    I am impressed by the figures! Do you know that in France the average income is €1500/month? So maybe we save proportionally more, but in absolute value I think the Swiss are well ahead!

    By the way, excellent site which allows to have a beautiful vision of an investor oriented towards increasing dividend yield. The famous magic of compound interest takes on its full meaning here.

    1. Hello. Yes, I know that income in France is much lower than in Switzerland. Be careful, if in absolute value savings are greater in Switzerland, expenses are also. Everything is much more expensive there than in France.

      Thank you for your compliments!

  2. Excellent article! I also regularly calculate the amount I would need to pay my expenses with my interests. Swiss salaries seem astronomical compared to salaries in other countries, but it is also true that life is extremely expensive.

    I regularly follow your blog and I appreciate it a lot because on the stock market side I have never had good results, quite the opposite. Good luck.

  3. Very good article indeed.
    Have you considered the impact of the wealth tax which, unless you live in SZ or NW, is rather high on assets of more than 1M CHF? Not to mention that you will also have to pay the full AVS on the entire fortune.
    I am in the same kind of thinking as you with an equivalent heritage.
    Not having yet put in place a real income strategy through dividends, I hesitate not to resume an activity (currently unemployed).
    One important difference, however: I am a tenant, which is very expensive in Switzerland.
    Sincerely
    Home

    1. Hello dom67, these are average figures at the Swiss level, so inevitably the wealth tax is accumulated here in compulsory expenditure and remains relatively discreet.
      What do you mean by "you have to pay the full AVS on your entire fortune"?
      Indeed, renting is a real steal in Switzerland (and elsewhere). If you can afford it, don't hesitate to buy. The rates are very low, but be careful with the purchase price, the market is very high.

  4. Hello Jerome,
    For couples, the wealth tax is bearable, but for a single person it is double!
    For the AVS, I mean that if you are a pensioner, i.e. without gainful employment, the AVS/AI contributions, compulsory up to the age of 65, are calculated according to your wealth.
    On 1.5 M CHF, this still represents 3000 CHF/year. Combined with the wealth tax, this starts to add up.
    For real estate, I would have to commit too many resources that I would no longer have to invest and generate income.
    And then there is the famous real estate bubble...
    Sincerely
    Home

  5. Very good article on the budget. It is indeed easier to master it when you know its components.
    For my part, I try to control my budget but without eating into my well-being. For example, my food budget is focused above all on quality (fresh and quality products but fewer superfluous products like sweets).

  6. Good morning

    Thank you for this source of information. For a concrete implementation as a French person… imposed in France… who wishes at 55 years old to enjoy life by investing his life savings, is your book / Excel applicable? What would you advise? Thank you. Patrick

    1. The book is a guide that can be applied to anyone. Everyone must of course define their own contours of the path they choose, but with this you will have a good foundation.

  7. Good morning,
    Have you considered creating an investment SARL? After a basic contribution, the vast majority of monthly contributions are in the form of a loan. You then accumulate an amount due to the shareholder which will be repaid in 10/15/20 years. Thus no taxation for a large number of years. For example, after 20 years at 25KCHF annual contribution, the SARL owes 500 KCHF to its shareholder, regardless of the value of its portfolio, and this, even before the interests (0.25% currently, but who knows if they will not increase to 1 or 2% in the future....distant).
    Subsequently, the company will pay a salary, but if it is outside the AVS/AI criteria, etc., the taxation will be low.
    Of course, with a tax rate of +/- 14%, reinvesting dividends will be more lucrative. The sticking point will be the taxation of capital gains and, of course, the individual taxation of the shares of said company as wealth, but no more than with individual taxation.

    1. Interesting idea. As you say, there would also be some sticking points. It would deserve a more detailed analysis to determine if this complex assembly is actually worth it.

    2. Hello William,

      I was very interested in your idea. I spent some time on it, imagining it and seeing what could be done.
      I must admit that undercapitalization is a bit of a concern for me. In my opinion, with an LLC and a relatively low base capital, undercapitalization will happen quickly, and the funds it will owe to its shareholder will be reclassified as equity and this will be less beneficial for the shareholder than having normal taxation since in a private person, capital gains are not taxed, whereas an LLC will also be taxed on capital gains...
      I will of course remain open to your response for any comments if I am mistaken.

  8. Hello Jerome,
    Post from 2013 but very interesting for the annual household expenses, I am at this level at the moment and I conservatively estimate that I (and my family 1 wife 2 children) would need something like 1.8 to 2 Mio CHF as capital once financially independent. I have a remark to complete these annual expenses (point 1) + a question on the cost of housing (point 2).

    1) For families with children, in my opinion, this transitional budget is missing a line item related to childcare (nursery/day mother/after-school care). Over about 5 to 10 years, with 2 children, this is considerable (and higher than my housing costs excluding depreciation) and can limit the ability to save for a few years... moreover, a Crédit Suisse study (https://www.credit-suisse.com/ch/fr/articles/private-banking/guenstig-wohnen-wo-sie-in-der-schweiz-am-meisten-einkommen-zur-freien-verfuegung-haben-202104.html) shows that these costs can vary from simple to quadruple depending on the municipality and canton of residence. It seems that VS, FR, NE and GE are advantageous in this respect, so it may be interesting to move to places where the housing/taxes/nursery-school reception trio are the lowest...
    Furthermore, do you also take into account in your calculations the capital on which to live the studies of the children who will have grown up... can this also represent a budget to be planned when the children are 15-20 years old...?

    2) How do you take into account your housing (RP) once you are financially independent? The 13,000 that you have (or had in 2013) represent the money put into a lost cause (mortgage + charges) but are not fixed over time (rates can go up). Similarly, if you amortize the mortgage after a while, the tax on the rental value increases… so the financial burden remains for me (cost of the mortgage -> transformed into tax on the rental value)… a solution as you proposed in another thread would be to rent out your first RP (to generate additional income) and buy a second one while gradually withdrawing the LPP assets to transfer them into the stone of your RP…

    I'm interested in hearing your thoughts in 2021/your 2013 post to see if you've also changed your capital requirements once you're financially independent...

    Thank you,

  9. Hi Sebastian,
    not really much change since this last post in the end.

    The 1.8 – 2 million you are talking about is a conservative solution in my opinion for Mr. and Mrs. Average. In my book I explain how this amount can be limited by various means.

    Regarding child custody:
    This can limit your savings capacity for a while, of course. However, as I point out in my book, it doesn't need to be huge. But above all, the goal is to gradually reduce your activity rate as you move forward on the path to financial independence => so childcare costs decrease at the same time. It all obviously depends on when you start on this path and the age of your children. As far as I'm concerned in any case, since I started early enough, I was able to take care of my kids (with my wife) for the most part. That's another advantage of financial independence!

    Regarding education, I have budgeted a fixed amount of savings since their birth to self-insure myself in a way.

    Regarding the main residence, we should not overestimate the tax loss compared to the reduction in the bank charge. Let's not forget that the taxman always ends up falling on us, sooner or later. And then there is, as we have already discussed, and as you mention in your comment, the trick of re-renting your first RP and buying another, while recovering your LPP. That's what I did.

    So no, I have not evolved in relation to the necessary capital, at least not upwards. I even made my decision to become financially independent with less than what I had planned to be honest, for different reasons that I mention in my book.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *